Friends of Mount Moriah Cemetery, P.O. Box 5321, Philadelphia, PA 19142

The Lost Soldier of the Civil War – Private William Jasper Christian

Private William Jasper Christian

Company B, 5th (West) Virginia Infantry, U.S. Volunteers (Union)

William J. Christian 5th WVA Inf Page 22William Jasper Christian was born about 1830 at Ceredo, Wayne County, Virginia (now West Virginia). On March 25, 1854, he married Mary Ann Hatton (1837-1918). They had four children. According to his medical disability discharge, he enlisted August 14, 1861 in the 5th Virginia Volunteers, Union Army, for a term of three years. His occupation was listed as farmer.

Having been “carefully examined” by a Union Army surgeon on September 2, 1862 and “found incapable of performing the duties of a soldier” due to “chronic nephritis,” Private Christian was then discharged from military service on September 16, 1862 at Fort McHenry, MD.

However, other records, including a “Record of Death and Interment,” indicate that this Private William J. Christian had died of typhoid fever at the Broad Street U.S. Army Hospital, Philadelphia, PA on September 12, 1862. He was also reported wounded at the 2nd Battle of Bull Run, August 29, 1862. According to the Union Army’s records, Private Christian was buried at Glenwood Cemetery, Philadelphia, PA.


But Private Christian never got to Glenwood Cemetery and the Union Army subsequently lost track of his grave. Instead, a Philadelphia death certificate indicates that Private Christian was actually buried on September 14, 1862 – at Mount Moriah Cemetery. Private Christian’s odyssey didn’t end at Mount Moriah.

Christian Page 4In 1891, the remains of 187 Confederate Prisoners of War, who died at various U.S. Army Hospitals in the Philadelphia area and buried in private cemeteries in Bucks, Philadelphia, and Delaware Counties, were removed and consolidated in an unmarked mass grave at Philadelphia National Cemetery, Haines Street and Limekiln Pike, in the Oak Lane section of Philadelphia. Among those removed from Mount Moriah Cemetery was a Union soldier, Private William Jasper Christian, now misidentified as a Confederate POW from Company B, “5th Virginia Infantry, CSA.”

The controversial mass grave remained unmarked, and the POWs unidentified, for nearly two decades while the United Daughters of the Confederacy and factions of the Grand Army of the Republic fought the Battle of the Monuments. The UDC wanted to place a monument commemorating 224 Unknown Confederate POWs who died in captivity, at Philadelphia National Cemetery. In 1901, a former GAR Commander in Chief and president of Philadelphia’s City Council, Louis Wagner, threatened to dynamite any monument commemorating “Rebels.”

On December 14, 1898, in his “Jubilee” speech at Atlanta, GA, President William McKinley (a Union veteran of the Civil War) advocated for the marking of 28,000 Confederate POW graves in the North. On March 9, 1906, Congress appropriated funds to establish a commission to identify and mark these graves. To settle the controversy in Philadelphia, in 1911, the government erected the first Federal monument ever dedicated to Confederate war dead, at Philadelphia National Cemetery’s mass grave.

CM PN 1 A-GThe Commissioner for Marking the Graves of Confederate Dead issued a report in 1912 identifying the POW graves remaining in the North. Among the Confederate POWs listed for Philadelphia National Cemetery on page 523 is Union soldier “W. J. Christian, Company B, 5th Va.,” date of death “Sept. 12, 1862.”

There is no record of any Confederate soldier, surname “Christian,” in the muster rolls of the 5th Regiment, Virginia Infantry, CSA. The 5th Virginia Volunteers (US Volunteers) became the 5th West Virginia Infantry in 1863, once West Virginia became a state on the Union side.

Today, Union Private William Jasper Christian’s name and unit can be found, misidentified as a Confederate POW, on the Confederate Soldiers and Sailors Monument at Philadelphia National Cemetery, third soldier from the top right column.

3 Comments on “The Lost Soldier of the Civil War – Private William Jasper Christian

  1. Great detective work, Sam. Do you think anything will be officially changed to correct this error? If there are any descendents of Union soldier Christian, have they been in touch with Mount Moriah Cemetery?

    Thank you for the work you do.

    Sue Facciolli

    • –Sue–

      Unless a descendant complains and requests a marker, the federal government will most likely leave the monument intact. There are other misidentified Confederates and possibly one more Union sailor, also misidentified, all associated with this monument. One Confederate was captured by the US Navy in Georgia, taken to Philadelphia where he died, then was buried in Boston, MA long before their was a mass grave. He’s listed among the 187 buried in the mass grave. There are also 3 civilian “Prisoners of State,” one of whom was held as a “hostage” by the Union Army, buried in the mass grave although there names are not listed. All 3 were from the Virginia counties that became West Virginia, same as Pvt. Christian. I believe Pvt. Christian has descendants today. His wife died in Kingfisher County, Oklahoma in 1918. He’s listed in the LDS database. I posted his information on Find A Grave. Maybe they’ll contact us.

      • As an addendum to this story, it’s possible that Pvt. Christian is still buried in Mount Moriah Cemetery. MMC’s burial register indicates that he was never consolidated into the Civil War soldiers’ plot, Section 200, Plot 1 and never removed from his original grave in another section on the Philadelphia side. Additional research since this article indicates that dozens of CSA graves supposedly removed from several Philadelphia area hospital plots never made it to the mass grave at Philadelphia National during “consolidation” in 1891. For example, only 128 of 160 CSA graves were removed from Chester Rural Cemetery in 1891 and that 40 additional were unaccounted for.